Every pitch tells a story

Every picture tells a story. True in life. True in history. And true in pitches. Whether you’re part of the agency pitch team or the client selection committee, every interaction is an image, a memory, and part of the dating process. What story do you want your potential partner to remember? The Initial Contact: Does […]
Agencies & Marketers: learn from the Beatles

The Beatles. Iconic. Immensely talented. Unprecedented success. And behind all of that brilliance and success, there is a strategy that brands and agencies everywhere can benefit from. The audience – their audience – often became part of the early Beatles experience through the band’s lyrics. In their music they spoke directly to their audience. Think […]
Win More Pitches: The Pitch Calendar

Just as you wouldn’t undertake an important client project without a timeline, why do many agencies participate in pitches without one? Successful pitch management depends on solid project management skills and planning. A good Pitch Timeline becomes your roadmap to a more successful pitch. What are the best practices for developing a Pitch Calendar that […]
How to Master the RFP Process and Land the Deal

From Better Experiences by Design with Susan Quinn. With Steve Boehler. How to Master the RFP Process and Land the Deal. Listen
Better agency feedback, better agency reviews

Why do we make sure agencies get fast, consolidated feedback after a working or tissue session during Mercer Island Group agency reviews? That’s easy: better agency feedback, delivered in a timely fashion, results in a better agency review for all involved. Here’s why it’s important and how to do it in your next agency review. […]
Choosing an agency in an AI world

How does a marketer best choose an agency in an AI world? Marketers and agencies everywhere are hard at work trying to make sense of what AI means for their business. AI platforms like ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Microsoft Azure AI, AWS AI/ML, Anthropic, Midjourney, Perplexity and others seem to evolve daily. It truly is a […]
3 things to do before an agency agrees to pitch

Your agency has been invited to pitch. Now what? Your hard work has finally paid off – your positioning work is done, your website is prospect perfect, you’re marketing the agency and you’ve built your network. And today an opportunity surfaced! It may be a warm lead, and inbound inquiry or even a formal RFP. […]
Pet Parents, Part 2: Ditch the Arrogance

Last week we talked about how using prospect language is a much more effective way to connect with your agency’s prospects. There is a sequel to this story, and it has a new moral: leave your arrogance at home. Remember the agency arrogance we discussed last week as part of the Pet Parents story? There […]
Pet Parents & Using the Prospect’s Language

Want to connect better with your agency’s prospects? Make sure you’re using their language. Not yours. If they have a revenue challenge, call it a revenue challenge. Not a sales challenge. If they have a sales challenge, call it a sales challenge. Not revenue or growth. Many of the words may generally mean about the […]
Avoid these 3 agency pitch mistakes

Most agencies want more at-bats. More opportunities. And they are confident that they can win if they just get a chance to get into the room with the prospect. In our work managing agency reviews for clients of all sizes, we see a different reality. We often see good agencies fail once they get into […]